C- a 3rd option Breath with both arms at the hips. Stops you leaning on the arm to breathe, allowed full rotation, was able to watch the arm pull. This version also helped the swimmer stop breathing so late into the armpit. I would also say avoid using a central snorkel for all these as you can stay flat and not realise as you still get the air.
So as usual we performed the 10min swim test in the Autumn at the start of the last course and at the end. Results can be found here
Look for the blue – blue denotes an improvement in the amount of distance you completed, beige means you held the same value. Keep in mind in order to improve you need to be swimming 3 times per week at least. Any less than this and you are in the plateau zone. Enough to maintain but not enough to break through. Swimming faster or further needs fitness, endurance and technique to all improve. The 3 are very much interconnected. Endurance is the ability to keep repeating accurate movements for sustained periods. Fitness is the engine to drive it but it needs to be a steady & accurate effort otherwise the water punishes you. If there is limited swim technique we get punished too much and even amazing levels of fitness will not be of use since water is so much denser than air.
The Autumn course is a hard one to improve on as many are race fit from the summer of competing and December becomes a hard time to focus and maintain consistency due to Xmas interruptions. If you did ‘only’ plateau then I would consider this quite an achievement. But don’t rest on your lane rope!. Now is the time to refocus and commit to ensure when we measure the success of this current cycle some big improvements have been made.
If you improved over 25m please drop me a line and I will put a gift in the post to you
Goodluck with the test!
It is going to feel rough but only by sticking with it and getting it done will it get easier. If you have not yet been back into the water then be prepared. After a break of a possibly a few weeks most of us are back to swimming this week. No sport seems to punish quite so much as swimming having had break from it. You will feel like a huge step has been taken, sadly backwards. Clumsy, lacking coordination and the water feeling extra slippery to name a few of the issues. This happens at all levels. Not just those new to the sport I promise. For the seasoned campaigner the path to feeling ‘normal’ should happen a little quicker but I promise we all suffer.
A few years ago I performed a lot of filming on week1 of our fitness courses in early January. I played it back and most were pleasantly surprised at what they saw claiming it was not as bad as they imagined. This is an important distinction here. Your mind and body will want you back on that warm sofa not swimming laps. I liken this to my last few KM of racing Lake Geneva last summer. I had completed 23km and the end was in sight for our relay team. I could see the fountain that greets you in the distance. My shoulders were so tired and ached so much. I was dreading to think how bad it looked.
“What is interesting is that in my mind my stroke was horrible, flat, scrappy and tired. My mind playing tricks to end the suffering! When I watched some of the footage taken of my final KM it was ok. Remember. It is not as bad as your mind is telling you.”
Prepare yourself for the frustration, cope with the demons telling you to get out. Set yourself a sensible amount and finish positively by getting the session done. Complete your swim with the SFT swim down to help realign your faltering technique as much as possible and help shape it before your next session. Try not to leave it too long before your next session so that all that you build on is not wasted, evaporating before your next session. 1 session per week is 6 days of unlearning. 3 sessions per week and you tip the balance in favour of swim positive week with progress rather then a plateauing effect.
So as a little xmas thing I have been trying to get to all our fitness sessions to film. Thanks to Maria for helping at Kings X while I was at a funeral. You can find your footage on dropbox. Click on the link to see your swims in real time then slow motion.
Walthamstow – Thurs AM
Kensington Thurs PM
St Pancras – Monday PM
From the submerged head on view – key points
Head still unless breathing, a few mm gap between the fingers. Symmetry of arm movements will keep you straighter.
Minimal exposure of the leg kick, keep them hidden behind the body. Not leaning on a straight arm to support breathing which will push you up, not pull you forward.
We should never see the palm of the hand from this angle. High elbow <I prefer wide elbow> but as long is it stays above the hand you are on the right track after an early pivot at the elbow <not the shoulder.>
Relaxed exhale through the stroke until the sharp intake of breath as you turn to breathe. We should not see the face from this angle! top of head, a little of the forehead. Look forwards but do not face forwards.
So this was pretty popular last year in the run up to Xmas so I am going to progress it slightly so it has an added twist. Thanks to Mr Trew for the original concept. Join us in Italy in May if you fancy more of this kind of fun, challenging swimming. Try one of these each week through to mid January to keep you focused and heading back to the pool frequently.
There is nothing quite like having some goals and targets to get you motivated and back to the pool frequently. Try these simple mainsets after a choice 400m warm and some build 25m to elevate HR <8×25 build each length slow to fast to get nicely warmed>
200m easy relaxed FC with good tech to swim down post mainsets as follows
12mins and swim as many 75m as possible resting 15secs. GO STEADY -record how many – 50m swim down
12mins and swim as many 75m as possible resting 15secs. GO STEADY -record how many – 50m swim down
12mins and swim as many 75m as possible resting 15secs. What was the number? 50 swim down
“Am I fit enough to enter a long distance swim? I want to do the Thames Marathon, The Dart, Coniston, maybe an Ironman.” I get asked this all the time and my usual response, if a little cheeky is ‘the only way to find out is to enter it.”
But…..races for 2018 are opening and people are entering….
This then usually kickstarts 2months of frantic training from a 6month plan and by week 12 we are fed up, tired and overtrained. The gloss of the event has started to fade and the summer months are still ages away. Enter by all means but then do not panic. Set things out and manage them with regard to sleep, work and family.
6months to a key event should comfortably be 50-60 swim training sessions, maybe 70 if looking to perform well rather than just complete. 60swims could easily be over 200km of blackline torment! Don’t try to get them all done in the first couple of months. Build the volume. You are asking your body to adapt to an overload of exercise and it needs to heal and rest to absorb this and then progress. Maybe limit month one to 9 swims maximum if you are starting from an unfit base.
Make use of your rest days, aid the recuperation with massage and stretching, work on your weaknesses, improve your flexibility. If injured do not add more sessions to your next weeks total to catch them up. Let it go. You do not want to further reduce rest time between sessions hindering the bodies ability to return to health. If you do not feel like it on a certain day due to a late night, sick child, work project then don’t go. If this happens for a week then you may need to re evaluate your goal, step back or divert to a different activity for a while as you recover from some overtraining and find your mojo again.
If you have mastered a streamlined body position, added rotation and can keep your head still unless turning to breathe then chances are you are probably swimming pretty well. What might the last area be to focus on? well last Saturday evening for a local charity a group of us swam 100x100m FC. It was interesting that for the most part the faster lanes managed to keep their technique for longer. The group was a mix of former club swimmers, fit and unfit, Triathletes and Openwater swimmers. If fit, the former club swimmers held on for the longest but in the end fatigue got to all of us. The main problem was a collapse in how we created our rotation meaning we then leaned on a straight arm pushdown to help us come up for air.
As I have said before poor technique due to fatigue is ok, it is inevitable and a byproduct of hard work. It should not be seen as a negative thing. As long as we repair, polish and restore it back to its former glory as soon as possible.
Regardless of ability the key issue that affected us all was the inability to create our rotation internally. By that I mean with an accurate leg kick helping drive our rotation and keeping us balanced we set up a good foundation from which to rotate the upper body. With the shoulders being moved from side to side we then have the opportunity to breathe smoothly
We lean on our arm as it pushes down and this helps us come up for air. What it does not do is allow us to move forwards since the hand and forearm are now pushing down.
When this happens the head and body come up and the legs sink leading to an uphill swim. One of the hardest things to perfect is a great catch position, many people get there but once the tired breathing starts we often revert to the straight arm push down. Last year I was filming a local tri club and the stats were amazing, only 2 from 40 were able to set this up correctly. The following is the shape we are looking for regardless of breathing or not.
I work on this with the basic Torpedo Drill to reconnect the leg kick to the body and how it rotates. Learning to rotate without the arms involved is key. Adding a central snorkel can help as you reduce the head turning but this does not get to the heart of the problem. If you are not sure if you are setting your catch correctly regardless of breathing or not then the Thumbcatch drill can help. This will help create a vertical forearm position with the fingertips pointing down and the palm pushing water back rather than down.
Quick fixes – paddles will not help this alone regardless of what is promised by the manufacturer. It is possible to push down with a straight arm whether there is a paddle attached or not, whether the hand is shaped in a fist or enclosed in a glove, bag or holding a dog toy. They might help you focus on the area that needs work but alone they will not encourage you to pivot at the elbow and set your catch. Large paddles might help you feel the upward movement but again will not tell you what the correct movement is.
Learning to pull with the hand and forearm is essential to go forwards faster but we must first correct the body position issues first to avoid issues when breathing tired.
Honest Swim Coaching.
Why do you recommend I start my race really slowly and build into it? ‘so I beat you.’
Why should I swim with my head in the water? is it more efficient? ‘yes and you will scare fewer people in the other lanes.’
Can I dive in please? ‘sure or how about just throwing your goggles into that lane over there and save yourself the trouble.’
Why should I kick with a smaller narrower leg kick? ‘ so you don’t kick me when I am in the next lane.’
Can I learn breaststroke yet? ‘no because that really hurts me when you kick me from the other lane.’
Can I learn Butterfly yet? ‘I think we are going to need a bigger lane.’
Can I use my pull buoy? ‘yes as a pillow at the end of this 10k set’
What should I do? I forgot my fins and paddles? ‘not put them on.’
Can I do this length Kick? ‘ok but the pool closes at 10pm’
Can I do this last 100m as kick? ‘Ok I am back here on Tuesday.’
I keep drinking water through my snorkel! ‘there are cheaper options as straws.’
I think my snorkel is broken? ‘stop using it on backstroke.’
Sorry I am late – ‘that is ok, it is not my finish line disappearing further in the distance as you struggle to drag yourself into T1 from a disappointing swim that you have to explain to your family and deal with the sad disappointed look in your children faces.’
How much should I reduce my kick by? ‘stop washing the ceiling for a start.’
Can I wear an orange hat for this openwater swim? ‘at your speed not a good idea. Unless you want 000s of people swimming around you in the corners.’
So I breathe in when I turn my head to the side? ‘if you can do it any other way then you are moving onto the advanced course.
Coaches are devious creatures, engaging all sorts of tricks to get you to try a little harder, swim a little faster or further. This will be of interest whether you swim or coach and will offer an insight into the coaching mentality and the pressure created by swimming in a group. When the two of these combine and work well, you will swim fast….
Many years ago Coach would offer us a get out swim. We would swim Mon-Fri, 5:30am to 7:30am with the club before school. As a reward we might be offered the chance to nominate one of the swimmers to step up, accept a swim challenge and possibly get out 15mins early if said challenge was met or time beaten.
Many of our club records were set during these get out swims. The elation and joy of possibly leaving just 15mins early led us to discover depths of energy and strength previously not discovered enabling superhuman speeds. Often best times would be set that we struggled to beat in major competitions. With the others in the lanes watching and relying on you, the pressure built. With the chance to let everyone out early and shower longer, walk slower to school or eat more at breakfast it was a deadly serious business. Olympic trials qualifying times were made during these swims! it was a chance to perform and no matter how many 000s of meters just swum it did not matter. Fatigue was not an issue.
Along similar lines I challenged out fitness swimmers with the following mainset knowing I would change the end option and see how they reacted. I am convinced that allowing swimmers to shape their own sessions encourages them to work harder. Or work appropriately to how they are feeling and yet find a way to dig deeper.
1×100 FC strong effort, 2×50 FC Stretch out recovery
repeat 2×100, 2×50, 3×100, 2×50, 4×100, 2×50.
The last block of work was going to be 5×100 also on 2mins
All were expecting it as i am quite predictable knowing how much I like a nice pattern! You can even see swimmers holding back on the 4×100 knowing what else is coming, you can see their pacing drop back a couple of seconds. Instead I offered a choice of the following after the 2×50 recovery.
6x 100 on 2:10, 5×100 on 2mins or 4x100m on 1:50. At this point the guys were pretty tired from the big block of work and I did not think the 1:50 option was likely. If it had been 3 some of them might have tried. Given the fatigue levels the 2:10 was my bet but once again I underestimated the power of group to get together, rally around and fight it out and not take the easiest option.
Often a mystery swim pops up to keep people guessing but this was a new challenge to let swimmers choose more distance with an easier interval, the predicted and expected set or a harder but shorter swim.
From a coaching perspective always mix things up, offer alternates, allow the swimmers some input into their set. Chances are they will work harder and you will all benefit. This block of work is named the creeper as it starts easy and the exhaustion creeps in. You could also make it harder by reducing the rest interval as the 100s go up.
1×100 interval 2mins
2×100 interval 1:55
3×100 interval 1:50
4×100 interval 1:45
5×100 interval 1:40
You could also go back up and make the set 3.4km which is a big block of work and ideal for Ironman. 1×100, 2×100,3×100, 4×100, 5×100, 4×100, 3×100, 2×100, 1×100 with the 2×50 stretch out between 100m blocks.
A group fitness session that is coached invariably gets you more excited to swim, to swim harder and faster. That is what we strive for within our sessions. The group cohesion comes together trying not let anyone get left behind. The camaraderie between the swimmers helps the group march forward into whatever I can throw at them. If you have not yet tried a fitness session with us come along and try it. Be prepared for devious methods to get you to try more and some enthusiastic peer pressure.
So, this cold/head flu/chest infection thing dragged on for 3 weeks. For me that is unusual. Most years it is a one week of nose blowing and sneezing and then get back to it. If you are athletically inclined than being out of action is no fun. It is like the expenditure of energy through training creates more and leaves me buzzing. Similarly, the huge amount of effort needed to get out of bed early and get to the pool for an early swim leaves me amazingly wide awake and bouncing for the rest of the day. At least until 2pm perhaps. Is it real or is it just that smug sense of getting something done while others are asleep? maybe a bit of both. On the other side of the coin when I cannot train the fatigue grows, the general daily malaise festers and the negative thoughts of how much fitness I am losing compound. After a strong summer of openwater racing and events <60km plus of events raced> come September I thought I was in pretty good shape. Fri Sept 13th was my last swim session and it had gone well. We were two weeks out from the masters National shortcourse Champs and I had the 1500m entered. Sat 14th I had the scratchy back of throat sensation and had started sneezing. At this point I was ok about it since for as long as I could remember I was a one week ‘cold’ person that was easily shrugged off. 7, then 10days came and still I was not right and certainly not able to swim.
The following was useful from my recent SCIENCE OF ENDURANCE TRAINING AND PERFORMANCE course from the Uni of Kent. I don’t think this was written with swimming in mind though and you need to think carefully about what might be feasible, what might be actually useful and what will hinder your all important recovery.
The Road back to Recovery –This brief guide is based on the article by Ronsen (2005).
Day 1 -NO strenuous exercise (very light exercise (e.g. heart rate less than 120 bpm) is OK if only above the neck symptoms (e.g. sore throat, runny nose) present. NO exercise at all if symptoms are ‘below the neck’ (e.g. muscle/joint pain, headache, fever, generalised malaise)…. Remember, exercising with an infection can be very dangerous!!
Day 2 – If increased coughing (or any symptoms worsen) or if any fever: NO exercise! If no fever or malaise, no worsening of ‘above the neck’ symptoms: very light exercise (heart rate below 120bpm) for 30 minutes is OK
Day 3 – If symptoms persist, consult doctor. If no fever or malaise and no worsening of initial symptoms: moderate exercise (e.g. heart rate below 150bpm) for 45 minutes is OK.
Day 4 – If no symptom relief, NO exercise and see doctor. If first day of improved condition, follow the guidelines below for post-illness return to exercise
Post-illness return to exercise
Ensure you have had at least one day without fever and other symptoms before returning.
Ensure full recovery for each session before undertaking the next session (you will probably take longer to recover than before the illness). Stop exercise and consult your doctor if: New episode or worsening of initial symptoms, or if fever develops. Persistent coughing and breathing problems in response to exercise.
Gradually increase back to normal training (taking at least the same number of days spent off due to illness before getting back to ‘normal’ training levels).
Pay particular attention to your tolerance to increased exercise intensity and take an extra day off if it feels harder than usual.
Swimming well is a highly cognitive activity and if you are distracted with a foggy head, struggling to breathe, coughing and spluttering I wonder how much you are really helping yourself. You probably are not helping your swim advance in any way and it is unlikely to be assisting your recovery. Maybe some head up kicking with a float to ease the strain on your breathing if you are only suffering ‘above the neck symptoms.’ Sculling could work well at this point. This will keep you in touch with the water and reduce that clumsy mechanical feel when you finally do resume full training. I usually refer back to my Christmas example and how swimmers after 10-14 days out of the water despite feeling mechanically dreadful in the water they are not as bad as they think they are, once we have reassured them with video footage. Don’t rush back. You are not going to lose the full mechanics of your swim stroke in 2-3 weeks. Each day you try to rush back to reduce your fading fitness inevitably you delay your full recovery which only further lengthens the longer project of getting back to full training.
I would not swim with ‘below the neck’ symptoms as described in Day 1 and to be honest I doubt you could do much to enhance any area of your swim even if ‘only’ suffering with above the neck symptoms. Day2 – if no fever or malaise present then perhaps you could work on some yoga or prehab exercises to keep the body supple. Stretchcordz are a possibility which will have you reproduce the swimming arm actions but allow the HR to stay low and not restrict the breathing in anyway. Day3 – if no fever or malaise then 30mins gentle full stoke made easier with a pullbuoy and snorkel to keep the heart rate down and the airways flowing with no restrictions. Providing you were already comfortable with a snorkel in the first place. Day4 – if feeling ok then start the Post illness return to training as described above.
As I went through this process as much as I wanted it to be over and for me to be healthy I had to stop myself training. Going in too soon was not going to get me fitter or stronger. I could have practiced some drills but I wonder how accurate they might have been and surely I could be accelerating my recovery with the extra time resting and sleeping.
Activities for long term time out of the water.
Watch some swim videos. You can study and learn. Be inspired to return to the water. Competition admin! start to enter those races. Many are opening and filling. Henley just announced the date of the 14km swim. Order some new kit to replace old/tired/not shiny. An eventual return to the pool with new kit will help. Take as many positives to that first session as you can. At the least rinse and shine those tired goggles. Rose tinted?! Start an online diary/training plan/commit and get accountable, plan to swim x metres each week and hold yourself to it. The Speedo On app and website are very easy to make use of. Revaluate your nutrition and diet. Is there anything you can do better to avoid such incidents in the future? Do you carry hand gel? combined with more hand washing <soap and water> this can help as long as it is over 60% alcohol. Read up on some of the great Tri books out there. Especially mine and Steves! Maybe this is the time to finally plan that training camp you had been promising yourself for quite some time.
Rest and get your sleep. I once read that you need 7 days to get over a cold with antibiotics or 1 week without. If you catch something then let it run its course. Make the time productive in other areas. I actually got some of my Xmas shopping done last week thinking I would then be free to train in the run up to xmas! Let us see how that one works out.